Circle Process: A Tool for Transformative Dialogue

Authors

  • NICOLE MENTING-WILSON Daemen University
  • Lori DeCarlo
  • Erica Fanning

Keywords:

Restorative Practices, Whole School Reform, Transformative

Abstract

A circle is a carefully crafted space for silence, reflection, and dialogue (Boynes-Watson & Pranis, 2015). Circles aim to be safe, inclusive environments, offering opportunities for honest sharing and deep listening. The circle keeper facilitates the circle activities, ensuring equity of voice, so no single view dominates another.  When we think of circles within the context of education, we commonly associate the process with a facilitative dialogue that is initiated after some conflict has occurred. However, the role circle can play within school settings transcends a mere response to conflict; it can be used to build a sense of community and provide opportunities for staff and leadership development. This article explores how being “in circle” can be used to break through a neo-liberal paradigm in education that has stifled both teacher and student creativity and learning. 

Author Biographies

NICOLE MENTING-WILSON, Daemen University

Dr. Nicole Menting-Wilson is an assistant professor at Daemen University's Master's Social Work program, where she develops curriculum content, instructs students, and maintains an active research and service agenda. Dr. Menting-Wilson research centers around the implementation of Restorative Justice practices and spirituality in education. 

Lori DeCarlo

Lori DeCarlo is president of Restorative Edge Consulting, LLC. As a former school superintendent, she supported the district wide implementation of restorative practices. Currently, she
provides training and coaching in the implementation of restorative practices to K-12 schools and for the New York State Education Department.

Erica Fanning

Dr. Erica Fanning is a nationally certified school-psychologist with more than ten years’ experience serving public school systems. Dr. Fanning has a passion for working collaboratively to establish school-systems that ensure positive academic, social and emotional outcomes for all student.

Downloads

Published

2025-11-24

How to Cite

MENTING-WILSON, N., DeCarlo, L., & Fanning, E. (2025). Circle Process: A Tool for Transformative Dialogue. Holistic Education Review, 5(2). Retrieved from https://her.journals.publicknowledgeproject.org/index.php/her/article/view/3295

Issue

Section

Peer-Reviewed Submissions